Precisely what does a beneficial opinion look like?
Would
- Validate your own testimonial having concrete research and you may particular examples.
- Be certain therefore, the authors know what they should manage to change.
- End up being comprehensive. It is the only big date you look at the manuscript.
- End up being elite group and you may respectful. The new experts will be understanding these types of statements too.
- Make sure to state everything you enjoyed in regards to the manuscript!
Cannot
- Strongly recommend extra experiments otherwise too many facets that are of extent into the analysis or even for the newest record standards.
- Tell new experts exactly how so you can revise their manuscript-you cannot need to do the things they’re doing to them.
- Utilize the review to promote your own browse or hypotheses. Læs resten →